Thursday, November 3, 2011

The Solution to Chicago's Managerial Quest

So at the request of the blog's favorite Cubs fan - obligatory Ellen McElligott shoutout - I was asked to take a look into the Cubs search for a new manager. If you haven't heard already, Mike Quade was fired yesterday leaving a vacancy in the Cubs dugout. A number of names have been kicked around including Terry Francona, Rangers pitching coach Mike Maddux (Greg's big brother), Brewers hitting coach Dale Sveum, Phillies bench coach Pete Makannin, Red Sox bench coach DeMarlo Hale, Indians bench coach Sandy Alomar and Rays bench coach Dave Martinez. But I have an outside-the-box solution for Chicago. You ready?
Photo Credit:

Bobby Valentine.

According to ESPN, this is what new General Manager Theo Epstein is looking for: "The next manager must have leadership and communication skills; he must place an emphasis on preparation and accountability; he must establish high standards and a winning culture; he must have integrity and an open mind; and he must have managerial or coaching experience at the major league level."

Bobby Valentine has over 1100 wins at the Major League level - he's won more than he's lost, led the Mets to the 2000 World Series, and won a Japan Series title with the Chiba Lotte Marines in 2005 - their first championship in over 30 years. So obviously he's shown that he's a winner.
Photo Credit:

But here's what I think separates Valentine from the other candidates. Bobby Valentine was a manager in New York City. Sure, I know the Mets aren't the Yankees, but you're kidding yourself if you don't think they face some serious pressure from the fans and the media in a position like that. And Valentine didn't just manager in New York, he WON in New York. Chicago is a similar situation. The Cubs need someone who can handle the fact that every move he makes is going to come under scrutiny. No disrespect to some of the smaller market teams, but it's a lot harder to manage the Chicago Cubs than it is the Kansas City Royals. Shoot, I bet you can't even name the Royals manager (it's Ned Yost).

No disrespect to the other guys in the conversation, but other than Francona and Sveum, none of them have managed at the big league level and Sveum has only managed 12 games. I realize that once upon a time Joe Torre and Bobby Cox had never managed at the big league level either, but neither of them were winners right out of the gate. Cox's Braves finished in last place in his first two seasons in Atlanta while Torre endured 5 straight losing seasons to start his managerial career while with the Mets. I don't think you want to throw someone into this situation in Chicago that hasn't at least figured out what kind of manager they're going to be. The Cubs need to win right now, and they need someone who is prepared to do that. So I vote for Bobby. Is that realistic? Maybe not, but I'd be shocked if they didn't bring in someone with a similar resume. It will be interesting to see how this situation unfolds in the coming weeks.


  1. The Cubs need to win right now? Have you not been paying attention? They are building from the ground up. Look to 2015 for a winner.

  2. The Cubs didn't bring in a high-profile GM like Epstein to blow up the team and try to win in 2015. While there will certainly be wholesale changes, these aren't the Astros or Pirates we're talking about. There is enough talent on this roster to win what is still a weak NL Central division right now. I fully expect the Cubs to be active in free agency this offseason and try and contend in 2012.

  3. Love it! So far, Theo has impressed me with what he has said and done. I respect him flying to Florida to tell Quade in person, as well as calling Ryno to inform him that he would not be considered.

    Obviously the sentimental side of me is now dreaming of a Maddux/Mad Dog combo, I feel as if we do need someone with a proven record of success. Once this is done (and I am guessing it will happen quickly), I am interested to see what happens with Zambrano....and Tim Kurj. said the Cubs WILL end up with Fielder...

    Sorry for the ramble. Keep up the good work!